I anthropomorphize things. Drooping houseplants (“Don’t worry, little plant, help is on the way!”), ornaments in need of new thread loops for hanging (“Don’t worry, little ornament, help is on the way!”), the children’s stuffed animals, especially Baby Star, who still occupies my son’s pillow, but no longer occupies his heart (“Baby Star, how did you come unwrapped?”). If I accidentally see a copy of “The Velveteen Rabbit,” I start tearing up. The children have heard the story, just not from me. I know it ends well, but that bit in the middle…
Years ago, in a collection of children’s Christmas stories, I read "The Fir Tree" by Hans Christian Andersen. It recounts an old-fashioned Christmas celebration, from the tree’s perspective. The trip from the woods, the bright ornaments and candles, the dancing children, then the attic, the woodpile and finally, the bonfire. I was distressed enough to skip over that story ever since. I also feel a tiny bit sorry for the post-Christmas trees I see at the curb.
My maternal grandparents had live Christmas trees while I was growing up, although I mostly “remember” this from pictures. When I was in early high school, my grandfather began his slide into increasingly poor health. Eventually, he was completely bedridden and barely functional for several years. It must have been around that time my grandmother purchased a little artificial tree. It had a sturdy metal base, a beautiful triangular shape with a righteous spread at the bottom (this was way before slim-line trees), and it sat on top of the atlas rack. Festooned with tinsel, colored lights and ornaments, this little tree was a constant at Christmas, no matter who gathered around it.
My grandfather passed away the year I graduated from college. Grandma stayed in their house another twelve years, but the time finally came for the household to be broken up and Grandma moved to a nursing home. The little tree went with her, or at least was put up in her room at Christmas.
When Grandma passed away in 2003, the little tree worked its way to our house, where I made it my “skater tree” and gave it pride of place near our big Christmas tree. A few bits of Grandma's tinsel still clung to the branches, wound tight by time, and the colored lights still glowed. It was a bit awkward to place, with the wide spread, but we made it work.
![]() |
| "The skater tree" |
Years went by. As the bottom branches drooped ever more alarmingly, we stopped trying to fold them up, and simply drew up a large trash-bag over the tree for storage. Then, the wires in a few branches broke, so they would not support ornaments at all. “I’ll get you another tree after Christmas,” my husband said.
“Not yet,” I said. “Maybe in another year.”
This past spring, I found another three-foot Christmas tree at our church rummage sale. The lights seemed to work, so I took it home, also in a black trash bag. This new little tree obviously had some history, although I didn’t know what it was, but I was happy to give it another chance.
We pulled the Christmas things out of the Christmas closet this past week. I brought the new tree up from the basement. I took Grandma’s tree out of its bag and fluffed it into shape, but on the floor this time. It wasn’t going up on the table this year. I sat on the floor and turned the tree around slowly, searching for those last strands of tinsel, placed there by Grandma so many years ago. I unwound them all and laid them on a pillow. Then, I took off the lights and coiled them up, marveling that they still work. I unscrewed the sturdy metal base, hoping it would fit the new tree. It didn’t, so I put it back in the Christmas closet. I put the now-bare tree back in its trash bag. With the base gone, I could tie the top mostly shut. I set the bag inside the back door, waiting for someone to bring the trash bin back up from the end of the long driveway. Once…twice…the fourth time I walked past the bag, I picked it up and brought it back in the living room.
“Here,” I said. “You can watch and see it will be ok.” I probably was reassuring myself. I carefully wound the dozen or so pieces of tinsel into the new tree, set it on the table and plugged it in.
As it turned out, only half the lights on the new tree worked. And, they were white lights.
“Would it be easier for me to just take all the lights off and put the colored string on, rather than replace all those bulbs?” My husband shrugged. “It’s going to be hard to get those wires off.” (Pro tip: Don’t try to unwire a pre-lit tree. It’s extraordinarily hard on the thumbs.)
I did get the white lights off, eventually. I wound Grandma’s colored lights into the tree.
“There,” I said. “You see? It will be ok.”
Three days remained until trash day. To their credit, neither of the children questioned the big black bag propped up on the sofa, even after the new tree was all decorated with skater ornaments. I had finally settled on a plan: I would take the almost-empty trash bin back down to the end of the driveway the night before. Then, on trash day, I would wait as long as I dared before carrying out Grandma’s tree and placing it in the bin, with enough room to keep it upright and close the lid.
The night before trash day, I had an idea.
“Wait! Watch this!” I reached into the tied-off bag and wiggled off the very top section of the tree, the section containing the absurdly long “angel-impaler” branch and three smaller branches. I tucked the little section into the back of the new tree.
“Look, part of you will stay here with us.”
This morning, I carried the bag with Grandma’s tree down to the trash bin. Almost forty years of presiding over Christmas has come to an end. I’ve drawn the front curtains, so I don’t have to see the truck come and go.
I wonder why it’s so difficult to let go of some things. Maybe it’s the memories they conjure up, and the fear that, without those physical object as reminders, those memories may disappear. I don’t know. I do know this long good-bye to a collection of plastic and metal in the shape of a tree makes no objective sense…but there it is.
